Aperiodic Tiling and Rhythmic Canons: A CP Journey

Abstract

The Aperiodic Tiling Complements Problem (ATCP) involves finding the full set of (normalized) aperiodic complements of a given pattern. This has become a classic problem in music theory, with some recent attempts to model it using Integer Linear Programming (ILP) and Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) frameworks. In this paper, we develop and compare different models of ATCP encoded with Constraint Programming (CP). The most effective approach admits two phases: a first one that allows us to merge (join) several subsets of linear constraints under the form of tables with large arity, and a second one that advantageously exploits the generated tables to discard periodic tiling complements. Our experimental results show that our approach significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art, solving every instance of a classical benchmark (standard Vuza rhythms for canons with periods set up to 900) in a time between 5 seconds and 2 minutes (except the largest instance being solved in 18 minutes).